How better IT asset recovery can improve business returns - GSMA Services

How better IT asset recovery can improve business returns

Understand how the circularity delta can help operators and enterprises measure recovery value, identify opportunities for improvement and make more informed decisions about retired equipment.

Retiring IT equipment should not mean overlooking its remaining value. For mobile operators and enterprises managing laptops, servers and phones, the challenge is to understand what they recover when equipment leaves its first life—and where better decisions could improve that return.

The circularity delta offers a financial lens on this question. This blog explains the metric, separates unavoidable depreciation from potentially addressable losses, and sets out practical ways to make asset recovery part of routine business management.

What does the circularity delta measure?

The circularity delta measures the difference between annual spending on electronic hardware and the net value recovered when assets retire, expressed as a percentage of spending. Peter C. Evans describes the concept as a way to make asset recovery visible to business leaders [1]. It focuses attention on financial outcomes rather than simply counting the equipment processed.

Formula:

Circularity Delta (%) = [(Annual Hardware Spend – Net Recovery Value) / Annual Hardware Spend] x 100%

For example, if a business spends $1 million on hardware in a year and recovers $100,000 from retired equipment, its circularity delta is 90%. This means it recovered the equivalent of 10% of its annual spending—not that the remaining 90% was wasted. The equipment also provided value while it was in use.

Why asset recovery deserves management attention

The wider resource challenge gives this discussion urgency. ITU and UNITAR’s Global E-waste Monitor 2024 reports that the world generated 62 million tonnes of e-waste in 2022. Only 22.3% was documented as formally collected and recycled in an environmentally sound manner [2]. These are global waste figures, not estimates of enterprise resale potential, but they underline the importance of responsible equipment management.

At company level, the circularity delta connects retirement decisions with financial performance. Unlike a macro-level measure of material flows, it considers spending and recovery within an organisation. It can give finance, IT and procurement teams a shared starting point for examining timing, resale routes and transaction costs.

Understand where recovery value changes

A headline percentage cannot explain every recovery outcome. The circularity delta framework identifies six factors that can help teams investigate the difference between original spending and net proceeds:

  • Economic Depreciation: The unavoidable drop in value as assets age.
  • Timing Loss: Value lost by retiring assets too early or too late.
  • Channel Loss: Value lost by choosing a lower-value disposition route.
  • Execution Loss: Value lost due to poor grading, pricing, or transaction execution.
  • Policy constraints: Security or compliance requirements that limit available disposition routes. These safeguards remain essential, even when they reduce financial returns.
  • Cost Drag: Value lost to fees, logistics, and other transaction costs.

Consider an illustrative $1,000 laptop: $670 represents depreciation, while a further $55 reflects other potential losses. These are hypothetical inputs, not market benchmarks. Their purpose is to distinguish value that age has already reduced from value that better timing, routing or execution might preserve.

Turn the metric into practical decisions

  1. Establish a baseline: Record annual hardware spending and net recovery for each asset category, including laptops, servers and phones. Define which fees and logistics costs reduce gross proceeds so that teams calculate net recovery consistently.
  2. Investigate the drivers: Use the six factors to examine where recovery value changes. Separate unavoidable depreciation and essential safeguards from opportunities to improve processes.
  3. Set targets and responsibilities: Agree realistic targets by asset class. Assign responsibility across finance, IT, procurement and compliance, rather than treating recovery as an isolated end-of-life task.
  4. Use market intelligence: Consider pricing, buyer demand and available channels when planning retirement and resale. Compare options against security, service and compliance requirements as well as price.
  5. Review performance regularly: Discuss results monthly or quarterly. Use the findings to refine retirement decisions and identify whether changes in process improve net recovery.

Read the results alongside operational measures

Financial and operational measures answer different questions. A volume-based measure, such as the proportion of units processed, shows activity. The circularity delta instead compares net financial recovery with hardware spending. Neither measure alone captures equipment condition, reuse outcomes or the quality of data handling.

The term ‘recovery rate’ also needs a clear definition: some teams use it for units or materials, while others use it for financial returns. Define the denominator before comparing results. Otherwise, teams can appear to discuss the same outcome while measuring different things.

Annual spending and retirement proceeds may also relate to different generations of equipment. Changes in purchasing volumes or asset mix can therefore affect the percentage without any change in disposition performance. Read the headline figure alongside asset-level information, costs and retirement timing before drawing conclusions.

Make asset recovery a managed business process

The circularity delta provides a starting point, not a promise of a particular return. Its value lies in helping teams ask better questions: what did we recover, what affected the result, and which decisions can we improve? Used alongside operational and compliance measures, it can bring greater discipline to asset retirement.

This is where GSMA Circularity Services’ enterprise asset disposition offering, delivered by RGX, can support the process. RGX connects equipment owners with certified service providers and supports competitive bidding, workflow management and reporting [3]. These capabilities can help teams compare options and manage recovery more consistently, without assuming that every asset will achieve the same outcome.

To explore how this approach could support your organisation’s retired equipment, find out more about enterprise asset disposition through GSMA Circularity Services.

If you’d like to explore how RGX’s enterprise asset disposition can be tailored to support your organisation, please complete our short form below and we will be in touch.










This blog was written by Peter C. Evans, Managing Partner at All Things Circular, whose expertise in platform strategy and the circular economy informs the discussion of enterprise asset recovery.

References

[1] Peter C. Evans, “Introducing the Circularity Delta: A New KPI for IT Asset Value Recovery”. https://www.linkedin.com/posts/peter-c-evans-phd-217b8_circulareconomy-circularity-itassetdisposition-activity-7490455891671130112-Xqqp

[2] ITU and UNITAR, Global E-waste Monitor 2024. https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-D/Environment/Pages/Publications/The-Global-E-waste-Monitor-2024.aspx

[3] GSMA Industry Services, “Enterprise Asset Disposition (EAD)”. https://www.gsmaservices.com/circularity-services/enterprise-asset-disposition-ead/